What is happening in the Chebarkul garrison. What to expect from the expansion of the Chebarkul tank brigade, which will become a division What to expect from the expansion of the Chebarkul tank brigade, which will become a division

Photo: Press service of the Central Military District

Chelyabinsk social activists openly declare: in military unit 89547 near Chebarkul, young conscripts are subjected to severe torture, humiliation and bullying by the command staff. Employees are robbed of their money for their work, beaten and humiliated. One of the soldiers, unable to bear the beating, left the unit, after which his wife and one-year-old daughter were threatened with rape. And the sister was told that if his brother did not return, he would be found dead in a ditch.

Ulyana Vinokurova, the sister of 24-year-old conscript soldier Maxim Tyumentsev, addressed Chelyabinsk social activists. At the end of December 2010, he was called up from Asha and served in military unit 89547 of the Chebarkul garrison in an engineering company, writes the New Region portal.

Nightmare test

In the summer of 2011, he was at the Azov training ground: together with other colleagues, he participated in the disposal of the projectile, then in preparation for the international exercises Center 2011. As the soldier’s sister managed to find out, this period became a nightmare for her brother: contract sergeants and commanders turned the life of young conscripts into a real hell.

“In this military unit, conscript soldiers are as if in a concentration camp, where Dagestani soldiers act as overseers and inquisitors. All this becomes possible with the encouragement of the commanders and the connivance of the military prosecutor's office of the Chebarkul garrison. Almost all conscripts at the Azov training ground were mocked, except for the Dagestanis, they are in a special, “honorable” position,” says Maxim Tyumentsev’s sister.

According to her, the rank and file were subjected to severe bullying and humiliation because of monetary payments. The fact is that for the disposal of shells, soldiers are entitled to a salary of 35 thousand rubles per month. Money is transferred personally to each person on a plastic card. However, as Vinokurova says, while the cards were kept by the commanders, money mysteriously disappeared from them. As it turned out, along with the cards, the company commanders kept full list PIN codes for each card. Therefore, the money was calmly withdrawn without informing its owners.

For example, one day Maxim Tyumentsev received an SMS message on his phone stating that 10 thousand rubles had been withdrawn from his account. And when the conscript received the card and managed to transfer the remaining funds to his wife’s account, his life in the military unit turned into a nightmare. The sergeants began to demand money from him, and when they found out that the bank account was empty, they became furious.

After this, as punishment, they forced the obstinate conscript to carry a bag filled with gravel on his back for 3 weeks.

“And he carried it everywhere - to the toilet, the dining room, ate and slept in it, after which he began to have serious problems with his spine. He was beaten so much that his brother’s 8 teeth were knocked out, he had a severe concussion after being beaten on the head with handcuffs, and his nose was broken. They beat me on the kidneys and liver with large sticks. And it happened like this: they drove him into a tent, forced him to strip naked and beat him with sticks, then doused him with water and beat him again. And after the mass beatings, the soldiers were forced to wash each other with washcloths,” says sister Maxima with tears in her voice.

In addition to all the injuries, the soldier developed periodontal disease. Now he can hardly eat, given that he is missing 8 teeth, the rest are very loose due to gum inflammation.

Rescue escape

According to the sister, other colleagues of her brother were subjected to exactly the same abuse in the unit. One of them, Vyacheslav Tikhonov, even tried to commit suicide, as a result of which he ended up in a psychiatric clinic in the village of Birgildy. Two more went on the run, but were returned.

Maxim Tyumentsev followed their example. He left the military unit without permission: on foot, through the forest, and in passing cars he reached Chelyabinsk. Let us note that his wife Valentina and her one-year-old daughter rented an apartment near the place of service. After her husband ran away, unknown people came to her several times. military uniform. They searched the apartment several times a day, even in her absence.

“One of the Dagestanis said to his brother’s wife with an accent: “There is no money, you will repay the debt to your homeland. First we will rape you, then we will get to your daughter,” says Ulyana Vinokurova.

Also, his company commander called Tyumentsev’s sister and threatened that if Maxim did not return to his unit, he would “be found dead in a ditch.” Later, the military used another method: they called and told the sister that her brother’s body had been found.

The woman came to Chelyabinsk, met with her brother and persuaded him to confess to the military prosecutor's office of the Chelyabinsk garrison and the military investigation department. Here they began a pre-investigation check on all of the above facts. The soldier managed to avoid criminal prosecution for desertion: he confessed voluntarily and within the prescribed period - no later than 10 days.

The soldier underwent a forensic medical examination in Chelyabinsk, and civilian doctors recorded all the beatings. Later he was sent to undergo a military medical examination to determine his suitability for service. However, surprisingly, the doctors at the military clinic did not find any concussion, spinal injuries, knocked out teeth, or a broken nose. The only thing the doctors did was to send the victim for a psychiatric examination, doubting his adequacy due to the fact that he escaped.

Injury to service is not a hindrance

In general, military experts recognized that the crippled soldier was fit for further service. Moreover, he was denied treatment, citing the fact that all the documents were in the military unit. By the way, investigators have not yet been able to obtain them - even after an official request.

Meanwhile, the conscript independently reached Miass City Hospital No. 2, where he was diagnosed with duodenal ulcer, atrophic gastroduodenal reflux, chronic cholecystitis, cervical osteochondrosis with serious curvature of the spine, which is a contraindication for military service. True, the conclusions of civilian doctors are not a decree for the military, that is, they are not grounds for exemption from service.

Maxim Tyumentsev’s sister appealed to the governor Chelyabinsk region, Commissioner for Human Rights of the region, Minister of Defense of the Russian Federation, Main Military Prosecutor's Office, Main Military Medical Directorate. She demands to take special control over the course of the investigation in this case, to bring to justice those responsible for what happened, including the military prosecutor of the Chebarkul garrison for neglect of his duties, and also to help send his brother for a military medical examination.

During the pre-investigation check, Maxim Tyumentsev was placed in one of the military units of the Chelyabinsk garrison, until he is in danger. However, relatives and social activists sincerely fear that after the investigation materials are transferred to the military investigation department of the Chebarkul garrison, Maxim may again be forced to return to the unit to participate in the investigation. It will be quite difficult to prove the facts of beatings and abuse: colleagues scared to death may refuse to testify against arrogant commanders and brutalized contract soldiers. But the latter can easily put pressure, including physical pressure, on a soldier.

According to the director of the “Conscript School” Valeria Prikhodkina, she will monitor the progress of the inspection and the fate of Maxim Tyumentsev and report this to the media.

Slave labor in training

By the way, Ru-Compromat already says that during the international exercises “Center-2011” near the city of Chebarkul, soldiers are kept in terrible conditions. The media reported that hazing and psychological violence, slave labor and unsanitary conditions are rampant in the exercise tent camp where conscripts live.

The mother of one of the conscripts, who visited the tent camp, told reporters about the horrors of army life for Chebarkul soldiers. What she saw there shocked the woman. Before her eyes, an old-time serviceman of Caucasian origin beat a young conscript. After the unfortunate man fell to the ground, the “grandfather” kicked him into the tent, where he continued to kick him.

“The worst thing is that officers and other soldiers passing by saw all this. Everyone treated this the way we civilians treat a passing car: we’ll go around the obstacle and move on. The officers saw me walking and looking at it. Of the 9 people I met, not one made even the appearance of stopping this. My son told me not to make any noise, otherwise he would be worse off than he is now. According to him, “now they almost don’t hit, they just pump.” They beat the soldiers casually and routinely, no one was embarrassed by my presence,” said the shocked mother of the soldier.

In addition to physical violence, psychological violence is also rampant in the unit, the woman said. One day, the parents witnessed the following scene: 4 soldiers lined up in a row near one of the tents, for some reason they stood on one leg, and with their hands they made something reminiscent of a Brezhnev gesture of greeting. Opposite them sat three “grandfathers” and cackled. “The feeling that this is not an army - this is rednecks with machine guns,” the parents cannot find another definition.

The soldiers spend 14-18 hours a day digging large holes with shovels and building a mock town, the woman said. They live in field conditions: without hot water. This is despite the fact that the temperature at night drops to zero. A tent designed for 22 people sometimes accommodates up to 36 soldiers. At the same time, young people often do not have enough space on the “bunks,” as sleeping places are called here, and they sleep wrapped in a pea coat on the bare ground. According to Olga Rodionova, she managed to hear these terrible details from a conversation between another conscript and his mother.

The bathhouse at the training ground is heated 2 times a week, only 15 minutes are given for washing. True, not everyone manages to wash themselves. Before washing, military personnel are examined by a medic. Considering that almost all recruits have purulent calluses on their feet, they are not allowed into the bathhouse so as not to spread the “infection.”

However, the “alarm” about the appalling conditions in the Russian army is being sounded not only “from below,” but “from above.” So, in the spring of this year, now former reserve major Igor Matveev posted a video message on the Internet to Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, in which he spoke about the outrageous facts known to him from army life. So, according to him, soldiers in one of the Vladivostok units were fed dog food, and the premises of the unit were illegally rented out to guest workers. The video quickly spread across the Internet and attracted the attention of bloggers and journalists. Under the influence of the excitement, the Internal Troops of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation initiated a verification of the facts stated by the major. However, very soon Igor Matveev himself found himself in the dock on charges of exceeding official authority and using violence against soldiers. On September 9, the Vladivostok Garrison Court found reserve major Igor Matveev guilty of abuse of office by using violence against military personnel and sentenced him to four years in prison with deprivation of rank.

We also note that the largest strategic exercise in 2011, “Center-2011,” started at the end of September in Russia, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan. The active phase of the exercises, as reported by RIA Novosti, ended on September 26.

On February 1, the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Chelyabinsk Region visited parts of the Chebarkul garrison. Alexey Sevastyanov met with the leadership of the tank and anti-aircraft missile brigades, the medical service of the military district and military prosecutors on a very sad occasion: since the beginning of January, two conscript soldiers serving in Chebarkul have died of pneumonia.

Chelyabinsk.ru has already written about both unfortunate cases. Private Dmitry Glebov, who served in the 7th Guards Tank Brigade, was sent to the medical unit on December 22, 2012, then transferred to the Chelyabinsk military hospital. When it became clear that there was no improvement, he was sent to Yekaterinburg, but doctors there were unable to help the guy: on January 13, he died.

Sergei Karabatov, who served in the 28th anti-aircraft missile brigade, went to the doctors on the day of his oath in the same December: he went on leave with his father, returned to the unit at 18:00, and four hours later he found himself in the first-aid post - he was diagnosed with an elevated temperature .

By the way, as officers of both units assure, even officially healthy soldiers communicate with doctors at least several times a day, starting with the morning formation. Head of the Medical Service of the Central Military District Anatoly Kalmykov In general, I am sure that for the army the peak of colds - both influenza and pneumonia - has already passed.

“The largest number of cases occurred during the New Year holidays,” said Anatoly Kalmykov. “The soldiers sat in the barracks, ran out of the warm rooms into the street for various needs - you can’t keep track of everyone. In general, the situation in Chebarkul is quite favorable, despite two deaths. In the Elansky training center, for example, there were no deaths, but there were many more cases of illness!”

Doctors, as we know, are generally cynical people, and for them, who are responsible for the health of tens of thousands of soldiers, two deaths in one garrison are a nuisance, but they do not represent anything unexpected or extraordinary. If we look objectively, then, according to military doctors, recently the situation with the prevention and treatment of colds has improved markedly.

“At the slightest suspicion, soldiers are sent to a mobile X-ray room,” he said. doctor-therapist at the anti-aircraft gunners' first-aid post, Alexander Esin.– The temperature exceeded 37 degrees – immediately fluorography, and, if necessary, hospitalization. My civilian colleagues come to us twice a week and anyone can turn to them. In case of sudden complications, an ambulance arrives at the unit within a maximum of 15 minutes. I spent many years in military medicine; I myself am a lieutenant colonel in the medical service in the reserve. Understand: long gone are the days when soldiers were simply not allowed to go to the doctors; now all commanders understand that it is better to avoid future problems by taking care of their subordinates in advance! As for the deaths... I did not observe Sergei Karabatov himself, but, apparently, already in the hospital, in addition to one type of pneumonia, another was added to him, which caused a critical deterioration in his condition. Besides, we can only guess where the guy managed to get infected: he spent the whole day walking around the city with his father!”

Be that as it may, the army is not talking about an epidemic on the scale of not even the entire military district, but at least the military garrisons: there are too few sick people for this. For example, according to Anatoly Kalmykov, in the medical unit of the 7th Tank Brigade, today there are 39 patients with acute respiratory infections, 12 soldiers with tonsillitis, 17 with pneumonia, 10 with bronchitis. In the 28th anti-aircraft missile system - seven with acute respiratory infections, four with bronchitis, three with pneumonia. By the way, no one keeps soldiers in units with pneumonia - they are immediately sent to a military hospital in Chelyabinsk.

And yet, despite the rosy reports, the deaths of young guys took place. Why?

“I do not deny that in the army, unfortunately, there are many still unresolved problems,” he shrugs. Deputy Commander of the Central Military District for Work with Personnel, Major General Alexey Tsygankov.– It is an axiom that it is easier to prevent a disease than to defeat it. Unfortunately, this is not always possible. There are commanders who do not pay enough attention to their soldiers. There are the soldiers themselves, in essence, very young people, yesterday’s children, unable to take care of themselves without parental help and not paying attention to the symptoms of the disease that appear. There are other problems. I can say one thing: there are much fewer of them than 10-15 years ago!”

The Ombudsman and the journalists who arrived with him were asked to familiarize themselves with the living conditions of conscripts - both healthy and sick. It turns out that in Chebarkul there have been no classical barracks for a long time, where up to a company of young people live in one room. Cabins with four to five beds. The temperature in living quarters is 22-25 degrees, in the dryer for clothes and shoes - up to 37 degrees. In several cubicles, plates with chopped onions and garlic are displayed on the bedside tables - soldiers are not limited in the consumption of these odorous products. This is not just a one-time show: Chairman of the Council of Chiefs of the Tank Brigade Igor Mikhailov confirms that his colleagues regularly visit units of the Chebarkul garrison, and warmth in the premises is in order. The rank and file themselves shrug their shoulders: they say, we, of course, remember and mourn Sergei Karabatov, but why such a misfortune happened to him - God knows!

“He was very thin,” recalled someone who served with him. a private named Dima.- Tall, but thin. Maybe that’s why I caught a cold so badly? I myself ended up in the medical unit with pneumonia in the first month, but, thank God, everything worked out.”

By the way, to spite human rights activists, the soldiers do not look intimidated or downtrodden. Well, no way. Even when the conscripts, who, by the way, were interrupted from classes, were left in the club premises alone with journalists and the ombudsman, all the officers from platoon lieutenants to Major General Tsygankov came out - somehow there were no complaints. The young people in soft uniform (and, by the way, all of them in felt boots) hesitated and giggled, but were in no hurry to express their problems.

“There are undoubtedly problems, they still told me about them,” summed up Alexey Sevastyanov. – But they are systemic in nature, you cannot get rid of them in one day and by the forces of one part. While conducting an investigation into the death of conscripts, the military prosecutor's office identified a number of violations and made proposals for their elimination. For our part, we will also carry out careful supervision and respond to all complaints, especially since soldiers are not prevented from getting in touch. Prevention of the same pneumonia depends not only on medicine - both food and constant attention to careless young people are important.”

As for getting in touch, it really does take place. Many conscripts, without leaving the barracks, post photos from their place of service on social networks. Communicate with civilian friends on forums. According to assistant commander of the Central Military District Yaroslav Roshchupkin, among the rank and file there are both normal forum users and classic online trolls. So it’s getting more and more difficult to hide something in the army every year.

Over the course of a few January days, two recruits died in the Chebarkul garrison. There is only one reason: bilateral pneumonia of particular severity. The public sounded the alarm, parents of military personnel are still scared to death for their children. What is happening in the Chebarkul garrison? Why did the military allow this tragedy to happen? How are the other soldiers feeling? Chelyabinsk Ombudsman Alexey Sevastyanov went to the tank and anti-aircraft missile brigades for answers to these questions. To where they lived last days 19-year-old boys Andrei Glebov and Seryozha Karabatov died, and the Vecherka correspondent also went.

A sanatorium without a single soldier's soul

Both military units are located on the territory of one large Chebarkul garrison.

We have nothing to hide, especially now, in the era of technology and the Internet,” says the head of the press service of the Central Military District, Colonel Yaroslav Rosshchupkin, “soldiers now have smartphones, they write messages in social networks, we have an electronic reception area on our website where you can complain. So what's the point? This garrison is one of the most prosperous in the area. And we ourselves admit that the situation with deaths is abnormal, which is why we arrange checks and work together with you.

First of all, those who arrived were invited to evaluate the living conditions of the soldiers. It turns out that there are no notorious stuffy barracks with a mountain of bunk beds here.

The guys live in so-called cubicles, consisting of four-bed rooms. The room is warm (25 degrees, and in the dryer for clothes and shoes - up to 37) and cozy, the windows have double-glazed windows with cute curtains, good bedside tables and cabinets. On the nightstands there are onions and garlic, designed to drive out any infection. The air in the rooms is fresh, the beds are made perfectly - you can see your reflection on the floor.

By the way, wet cleaning is done by a woman, a civilian employee; the guys are exempt from these duties (according to the reforms). There is a small gym with a punching bag and all kinds of equipment, as well as a tennis table. So, in general, these cubicles resemble a good Soviet sanatorium. But without a single soldier's soul. " Guys in class“, the military said in one voice. " Well, so be it“, - flashed through our heads.

Weak fighters or fatal coincidence circumstances?

The next stop on the route is the first aid station of the anti-aircraft missile military unit. This room is even warmer than in the cockpits - according to the rules, this is how it should be. Today there are ten children here with acute respiratory infections, but all are already at the stage of recovery.

At the slightest suspicion, we send a soldier to a mobile X-ray room; if the temperature exceeds 37 degrees, immediately fluorography, if necessary, hospitalization,” lists general practitioner Alexander Yesin. - In case of sudden complications, the ambulance arrives at the unit in a maximum of 15 minutes. Understand: there is no point in hiding the pneumonia epidemic! We are responsible for every case. This is the same as accusing me of negligence! Now is not the time when soldiers are not allowed to see doctors. All commanders understand that it is better to avoid future problems by taking care of their subordinates in advance.

Every day the fighters undergo a medical examination. A doctor comes to them, takes their temperature, examines their skin, and inquires about their well-being. If necessary, medical assistance is provided immediately. However, if everything works so smoothly and efficiently, the question arises: why do the guys die?

Apparently, this is a fatal coincidence of circumstances,” the military doctor’s voice changes, “I can say for sure that help was provided to Sergei Karabatov as soon as he went to the first-aid post. Fluorography - on the same day, ambulance, hospital... Most likely, already in the regional hospital the bacterial infection was joined by a viral one, which caused a sharp deterioration in the condition. The doctors fought for his life and did everything they could. In addition, one can only guess where he fell ill - on the day of the oath, the guy took a long walk with his father around the city.

Meanwhile, doctors in uniform blame the weak immunity of recruits and poor physical fitness. This is what makes the infection spread so easily.

The number of conscripts who have category “A” for health reasons, that is, the healthiest, inevitably falls by 5% every year,” Anatoly Kalmykov, head of the medical service of the Central Military District, uses figures. - Moreover, in each draft, about 30% of the guys are smokers with 2 years of experience! In addition, there is a passive lifestyle: almost everyone is obsessed with the Internet; only 10% of conscripts are actively involved in sports.

However, despite the disappointing facts about our soldiers, doctors say that there is no epidemic of pneumonia in the garrison, there are too few sick people for this. According to Anatoly Kalmykov, in the seventh tank brigade today 39 people are suffering from acute respiratory infections, 10 are suffering from bronchitis, and 17 soldiers are suffering from pneumonia in the regional hospital. As for the anti-aircraft missile forces, there are even fewer: seven people are suffering from acute respiratory infections, four are suffering from bronchitis, and three soldiers are suffering from pneumonia.

Hassle-free recruits

They finally showed us the soldiers. And even those with whom Seryozha Karabatov served. About 30 guys were brought to the assembly hall straight from classes. At the sight of a delegation with so many military leaders, the guys, as if on cue, straight and well-trained, saluted and after the usual “at ease!” fell into chairs. Alexey Sevastyanov made an attempt to have a heart-to-heart talk with them, but the fighters were in no hurry to dump their problems. Even when all the commanders left the hall, only the ombudsman continued to break the silence. At the same time, the guys did not look at all downtrodden and intimidated. Then the journalists asked the main question that worries everyone about Seryozha Karabatov. Among the fighters there was his comrade. The guys are practically fellow countrymen, which is why they communicated even before the oath of office in the company of young recruits. Dima also suffered from pneumonia. Only he was luckier.

Apparently, a lot depends on the body,” says the recruit. - Seryozha was thin, clearly underweight. How did he get into the army? Not clear. By the way, he didn’t have any special symptoms, just a mild cough. And then... I met him at the regional hospital when I myself came down with pneumonia. He was pale, weak, high temperature held on. I was cured and went back to my unit. Then the commander said that he was getting worse and worse and was worried. And then they announced it to us. I couldn’t believe it, because I was cured, I thought: he will be cured too!

Dima believes that Sergei should not have joined the army at all. But when they undergo a medical examination, they are not particularly eager to examine the guys. According to the recruit, everything is decided after the cherished question - “are there any complaints?” If there are none, the guy goes to serve. And here no one cares what kind of immunity there is or whether there are any undetected diseases.

But military unit the boy protects as best he can.

“I thought it would be worse,” says the recruit. - When we arrived here, I was even surprised. The commander is good, they feed you enough to eat (for example, they offer a choice of dishes for lunch), we watch movies on Sundays, and they let you go with your parents on furlough. Health checks every day; if it’s minus five outside, we don’t go out to the parade ground. The conditions here are very good.

Fly in the ointment

However, Alexey Sevastyanov believes that there are still problems in such a prosperous garrison.

But these problems are systemic in nature; they cannot be solved in one day on the territory of one military unit, the commissioner concluded. For example, medical units do not have enough equipment to identify certain viruses, which are constantly changing and require different treatments. However, the prevention of pneumonia depends not only on medicine; constant attention to careless young people is also important. In addition, there is also a human factor - the prosecutor's office has opened criminal cases regarding the deaths of soldiers. For our part, we plan to continue to exercise strict supervision and respond to all complaints from military personnel.

Our delegation leaves the Chebarkul garrison. Soldiers return from training to warm cockpits. Life continues to be in full swing. But no matter how comfortable the Chebarkul garrison was, no matter how convincingly and accurately the military leaders spoke when complaining about the frail boys, no matter how sorry the doctor was for the guys in his medical unit, the fact of the guys’ deaths remains a fact. And you won't bring the guys back. This means that those same “systemic violations” need to be changed and eliminated. After all, our guys shouldn’t die in peacetime. They shouldn't.

"Evening Chelyabinsk" Anna Rybakova. This material was published on the BezFormata website on January 11, 2019,
Below is the date when the material was published on the original source website!

A K T
Commission visit to a military unit

02/04/2015 Chebarkul

Commission consisting of:
Shibanov Yuri Nikolaevich – Deputy Head of the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights for the Chelyabinsk Region,
Kovalev Alexey Alexandrovich – Assistant to the Commissioner for Human Rights for the Chelyabinsk Region,
Prikhodkina Valeria Yurievna – member of the public supervisory commission of the Chelyabinsk region,

On February 4, 2015, in connection with the report of the death of a conscript soldier in military unit 89547, Mikhail Sergeevich Gudelev visited military unit 89547, stationed in the Chebarkul garrison of the Chelyabinsk region.

When visiting the Chebarkul garrison, representatives of the HRC and the PMC of the Chelyabinsk region were present: Deputy Commander of the Central Military District (CMD) for educational work S.N. Poletuchy, First Deputy Military Prosecutor of the Central Military District S.V. Ashikhin, Acting Military Prosecutor of the Chebarkul Garrison K.R. Shamsutdinov. , Head of the military investigation department for the Chebarkul garrison Medvedev M.Sh., commander of military unit 89547 Kulakov K.D., representative of the parent committee Ovchinnikova I.V., representative of the Chelyabinsk diocese Father Dmitry.

During the inspection, employees of the HRC and PMC visited the headquarters of military unit 89547, where they met with the above-mentioned representatives of the Central Military District, the prosecutor's office, the VSO, and the command of the unit. During the conversation, it was established that upon the death of Private Gudelev M.S. carried out: by the command, an official inspection; on the part of the prosecutor's office, an inspection of the safety of life and health of military personnel and the military investigation department is conducting a preliminary investigation into a criminal case against the platoon commander of the first motorized rifle company Gorodner A.A., who has been charged under clauses “a” and “c” .3 art. 286 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (exceeding official powers, committed with the use of violence or with the threat of its use and causing grave consequences) in relation to the deceased Gudelev M.S. and paragraph “a” of Art. 286 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation in relation to another serviceman, Private X.. A number of examinations have been appointed and are being carried out in the criminal case, including after collecting complete characterizing documents, a comprehensive psychological and psychiatric examination will be appointed.

According to the meeting participants, there are grounds that the death of Private Gudelev M.S. occurred as a result of murder, and not suicidal actions, no, although during the preliminary investigation all versions of what happened will be checked. In particular, such a conclusion can be drawn by studying Gudelev’s email correspondence with friends, where he writes, “that after the shooting he found a cartridge, cleaned it of prints and hid it in the barracks, in case he got everything, but they still often get weapons.”

In addition, the command reported that from January 2 to January 4, 2015, Gudelev was on leave due to the arrival of his parents on the occasion of his mother’s birthday, after the departure of his parents from January 5 to January 7, 2015, he was in the medical unit due to illness An acute respiratory infection, he came to the company healthy, did not complain about anything. Daily physical examinations of the platoon servicemen did not reveal any signs of beatings on Gudelev and his colleagues.

Also during the meeting it was established that senior lieutenant Gorodner A.A. commands a platoon for only a month and a half; before being drafted into the RF Armed Forces, he served under a contract in the Main Directorate of the Federal Penitentiary Service of the Russian Federation in the Chelyabinsk Region, although he has a higher general military education (graduated tank school). Before this, a junior sergeant, a conscript and who knows more about the state of the platoon than an officer, acted as platoon commander for a long time.

In addition, the VSO went to court with a petition to elect Gorodner A.A. against the accused. preventive measures - detention, but the Magnitogorsk Garrison Military Court refused to satisfy this petition, this decision was not appealed.

Next, the commission went to the first motorized rifle company, where a conversation was held with the servicemen on conscription of the platoon where M.S. Gudelev served. All soldiers are dressed and wearing shoes in uniform, the uniform is new. As a result of the survey, no complaints about living conditions were received. Cell phones are not taken away from anyone; they have the opportunity to contact parents on weekends, and in case of emergency, on weekdays.
There are information stands where hotlines, telephone numbers of the military prosecutor's office, doctors, etc. are indicated, and there is also an internal telephone number that you can call. Are engaged physical training, combat training and study of the General Military Regulations of the RF Armed Forces. According to the soldiers, there were no cases of hazing, except for those cases of hazing by Senior Lieutenant A.A. Gorodner. to the deceased Gudelev M.S. and Private Kh., who are in the criminal case under investigation.

Regarding the incident, the soldiers explained that on January 28, 2015, at about 12.50 minutes, seven servicemen returned from the park from combat training to the company, the rest still remained in the park to hand over equipment and were preparing to hand over weapons, which were issued without ammunition for the above-mentioned training . Private Gudelev went to the office to get a piece of paper to write a report on the surrender of weapons, from where the shot was fired. Colleagues ran into the office, where there was no one except Gudelev, who was lying with a head wound, and then reported what had happened on command. At the same time, the servicemen who came with Gudelev to the company added that during the movement from the park Gudelev looked normal, was depressed, was not withdrawn, did not talk about any problems, they could not explain what caused the incident.

All soldiers are dressed and wearing shoes in uniform, the uniform is new. Representatives of the HRC and PMC were given the opportunity to talk with Gudelev’s colleagues in the absence of commanders and other persons. As a result of the survey, no complaints about living conditions were received.

However, upon inspection of two “cubbies” on the first floor of Soldiers’ Dormitory No. 7, violations of the sanitary condition of the bathrooms were revealed. Command representatives received an explanation that maintenance buildings is carried out by the Oboronservis company.

Also, when visiting the canteen, questions arose about the quality and organization of catering by the outsourcing company.

The questions were verbally voiced to representatives of the military prosecutor's office of the Central Military District and the military prosecutor's office of the Chebarkul garrison. An official appeal on these issues is currently being prepared to this supervisory authority to carry out appropriate inspections.

• September 2nd, 2014 , 02:26 pm

Tomorrow, together with the media, the Commissioner for Human Rights will visit the Chebarkul garrison. Departure from 75 Sonya Krivoy St. at 10-30.

I ask the media to send to Yaroslav Roshchupkin, press secretary of the Central Military District, at [email protected] Full name of correspondents with indication of media.

Topic: Conscript said goodbye to his parents and opened his veins

Alexey Tabalov's information is confirmed. A conscript soldier of the anti-aircraft brigade A....... Sergei was admitted to the hospital with cuts. These events occurred at the test site. Monday-Tuesday he intends to meet with Sergei to clarify the circumstances of the suicide attempt. I hope to take part in the inspection together with the control authorities.

The head of the Chelyabinsk project “Conscript School” Alexey Tabalov is checking a message received from Kemerovo from the parents of a soldier who serves in the Chebarkul division. “The conscript called home to say goodbye to his parents and said that he had opened his veins. Information has not been verified. The conscript’s parents told about this,” Tabalov told a URA.Ru correspondent.

Let us note that the military often calls military unit 89547 in Chebarkul almost exemplary. But there are problems, and significant ones. It is enough to recall only a few episodes over last year. For example, Dmitry Glebov (conscript from Chelyabinsk), Sergei Karabatov (Zlatoust), Sergei Markin (Miass) died of pneumonia. Inspections showed a lot of violations, and the management got off with disciplinary sanctions. Former commanders of tank companies, senior lieutenants Alexander Prilutsky and Sergei Chernavsky, received 3.5 years in prison for brutally beating contract service junior sergeant Yevgeny Efanov, and then holding him in the basement to hide their crime.

• May 21st, 2014 , 05:39 pm

On May 20, 2014, in accordance with the Action Plan of the joint working group of the Main Military Prosecutor's Office and the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights in Russian Federation in the club of military unit 71316 (Chelyabinsk region, Chebarkul-12, military town) a joint reception of military personnel, citizens discharged from military service, and members of their families, as well as conscripts was organized.

The joint reception was conducted by the leading consultant of the Office of the Human Rights Commissioner in the Russian Federation V.A. PROKHORENKOV; Military Prosecutor of the 1st Department of the 3rd Directorate of Supervision of the State Military Prosecutor's Office, Lieutenant Colonel of Justice V.V. GERASIMOV; Commissioner for Human Rights in the Chelyabinsk Region SEVASTYANOV A.M.; Senior Assistant Military Prosecutor of the Central Military District, Colonel of Justice R.G. KOZLOV; Military prosecutor of the Chebarkul garrison, Lieutenant Colonel of Justice D.P. SHUVARKIN and other heads of specialized departments.
()

Representatives of the military units of the Chebarkul garrison, the Chelyabinsk Regional Military Commissariat, the Chelyabinsk branch of OJSC Slavyanka, the branch of the 354th district military clinical hospital, the Federal State Institution "CenterRegion Housing" of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, the Federal State Institution "Privolzhsko-Uralskoye" also took part in the reception of citizens territorial administration property relations of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, FKU OFO of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation in the Kurgan, Tyumen Chelyabinsk region, Chebarkul ERT branch "Ekaterinburg" of OJSC REU. The head of Chebarkul, A.V. Orlov, was also invited.

During the work of the public reception, 57 citizens were received on issues of legislation on military duty and military service, housing legislation, criminal and criminal procedural legislation, labor and civil legislation.

The majority of reserve servicemen and members of their families addressed the issue of housing legislation, 41 people in total.

The main question that concerned citizens was the transfer of residential premises from the status of official housing to municipal housing with the aim of its further privatization.

On October 11, 2011, Order No. 1779-r of the Government of the Russian Federation was signed, by which the Chebarkul military town was excluded from the housing stock of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. However, most of the apartments in which reserve and retired military personnel, members of their families, as well as RA employees live, have official status.

Changing the status of this housing is within the competence of the Minister of Defense of the Russian Federation, in connection with which the complaints of the citizens who applied were accepted for prosecutorial inspections by representatives of the military prosecutor's office of the Central Military District, some of the complaints were accepted by the leading consultant of the Office of the Human Rights Commissioner in the Russian Federation V.A. Prokhorenkov. for consideration by the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation; A number of complaints were accepted by the HRC in the Chelyabinsk region Sevastyanov A.M. to conduct an inspection within the scope of its competence.

Yes, according to this issue Citizen Vera Ilyinichna Kotenko, the widow of reserve officer V.D. Kotenko, who lives in the Chebarkul military town, contacted the commissioner.
According to the applicant, her husband served in the army for 24 years, was transferred to the reserve in military rank"Major", she served as a civilian member of the Armed Forces for 31 years. During his service, the husband was allocated an apartment, and it was not included in the official status, but later, by order of the RF Ministry of Defense, the apartment received the “official” status.
The husband did not wait for this status to be lifted, he died, now the military camp has opened, but the status of “official” housing has not been removed from the apartment, she cannot achieve this and will privatize it in the future or dispose of it, leaving it to the children. At the same time, if there are still cases of housing privatization among military and reserve military personnel on the part of the RF Ministry of Defense, then after the death of her husband, the higher officials of the Federal State Institution “CenterRegion Housing” of the RF Ministry of Defense in Yekaterinburg and the Housing Distribution Department of the RF Ministry of Defense do not want to communicate with her.
Kotenko asks the commissioner to help with the issue of “dispossession” of residential premises and the possibility of privatizing them. The appeal was accepted by the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Chelyabinsk Region with the aim of appealing to the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation to remove the official status from the applicant’s apartment and to go to court to make a decision on the privatization of her apartment.

One more example to illustrate. Citizen Olga Pavlovna Kozhevnikova, who lives in the Chebarkul military town, contacted the commissioner.
According to the applicant, she moved into the said apartment with her son on the basis of a warrant issued by a decision of the housing commission of the sanatorium. This residential premises is in federal ownership, which is currently managed by the RF Ministry of Defense.
In accordance with the Decree of the Head of the municipal formation “Chebarkul City District” dated November 25, 2008 No. 1100, taking into account the order of the Federal Agency for Federal Property Management dated June 30, 2008 No. 749-r “On the gratuitous transfer of property in federal ownership, assigned with the right of operational management to the Chebarkul apartment-operating part, into the ownership of the municipal formation "Chebarkul City District", residential premises located in multi-apartment residential buildings Nos. 26 and 44 were transferred in the prescribed manner to the ownership of the district according to the list.
She does not know by whom, on what basis and by what criteria this list was agreed upon, signed and approved, but her apartment No. 29 remained in the “official” status, which deprives her of the Constitutional right to privatize and take ownership.
The citizen asks for the assistance of the authorized and officials of the military prosecutor's office and the municipal formation "Chebarkul City District" in removing the status of "official housing" of the applicant's apartment and the possibility of privatizing it.

Alexey Sevastyanov, Commissioner for Human Rights in the Chelyabinsk Region, comments on the situation:

“A system error has occurred. It was originally laid down when allocating housing to military personnel. Then, because of this systemic error, citizens were evicted from their homes, warrants were invalidated, and other measures were taken that violated citizens’ rights to housing. We received a lot of such requests. We are preparing a special conclusion together with the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation, Ella Pamfilova, sending a request to the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation and issuing a special order.
A similar practice in the Russian Federation has already been carried out using the example of military unit 90600, which is stationed in the military town of the Roshchinsky garrison, 30 km from Samara, where those who received official housing received the right to privatization. The housing stock in the Chebarkul military town was not transferred to the municipality, citizens cannot exercise their right to privatization. An immediate response is required, since people have not been able to exercise their rights for 15 years.
A city that was previously closed becomes a hot spot. In fact, people living in the city are divided into two castes: those who were able to exercise their right to privatization, and those who were deprived of this right. All these contradictions resulted in a heated debate; we practically observed the situation of “serfdom.” In the 21st century, such things are unacceptable.”

In addition, the conscripts, as well as the conscripts’ mothers, were consulted on the issue of passing the military commission by employees of the regional military commissariat. It was decided to conduct a thorough medical examination of citizens of military age.

Citizen Natalya Aleksandrovna Kudryakova, the mother of a citizen of military age, Nikita Aleksandrovich Kudryakov, addressed this issue, who is appealing the actions of officials of the department of the military commissariat of the Chelyabinsk region in the Metallurgical district of Chelyabinsk.
The applicant indicated that her son was diagnosed with numerous diseases: perinatal damage to the central nervous system, hydrocephalic syndrome, movement disorder syndrome, hyperexcitability syndrome, adenotopia, myopia, scoliosis, meter valve prolapse and a number of others, and therefore he falls into the category: limited fitness military service and is not subject to conscription.
The presence of the above diseases is confirmed by medical documents. However, the medical conscription commission of the department of the military commissariat of the Chelyabinsk region for the Metallurgical district of Chelyabinsk did not take into account the health condition of N.A. Kudryakov, the presence of the above somatic diseases that entailed refusal of conscription into the RF Armed Forces, and sent the latter for a psychiatric examination, with something she and her son strongly disagree with. During the reception, a representative of the UWC called the draft commission of the Metallurgical District, and an agreement was reached on the conscript’s arrival at the military registration and enlistment office on May 26, 2014, where he would be scheduled not for a psychiatric examination, but for an examination of his neurological disease.

Employees of the military prosecutor's office and the HRC also provided consultations to citizens who applied on the investigation of criminal cases, payment of insurance amounts, payments to a combat veteran, rental of premises in the town and the garrison officers' house, as well as on other issues. All applicants were given qualified answers.

Citizen Yuri Leonidovich Chernyaev, who lives in the Chebarkul military town, also applied.
The applicant requests that measures be taken against the Chelyabinsk branch of Slavyanka OJSC, which has service houses in the town on its balance sheet. The house requires major repairs, there is a huge amount of water in the basement, which causes the foundation to be washed away and the house to feel like it is “moving”; therefore, light bulbs constantly burn out due to moisture, and at night in the hallways you can fall and get injured.
In entrance No. 5, the switchboard burned out, the wires are sagging and could fall on the residents’ heads, the ceilings in the entrances are black, whitewashing and painting have not been done for a long time. Repeated appeals to officials of Slavyanka OJSC were ignored. He asks to contact the relevant authorities to take action.

The Commissioner for Human Rights in the Chelyabinsk Region, Alexey Sevastyanov, drew attention to another problem - an appeal received to preserve the library collection in the town.

Citizen Marina Arkadyevna SEDOVA addressed the commissioner regarding the safety of the library collection of the military garrison. Residents of the military town bought the garrison library from the Russian Defense Ministry in order to preserve it for the future generation. However, there is no room for its maintenance and preservation. He asks officials to allocate premises in the garrison officers' house, which currently requires major repairs, especially since the town has “opened”, and buildings and structures have been transferred to the disposal of the municipality.

“Residents bought the library from the Ministry of Defense,” says Sevastyanov, “and transferred it to the municipality. The regional Ministry of Culture and the head of the city of Chebarkul should speed up the process. The library is a cultural center, and it should remain the basis for preserving and enhancing cultural traditions.”

• May 20th, 2014 , 03:19 pm

In accordance with the Action Plan of the joint working group of the Main Military Prosecutor's Office and the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation for 2014, representatives of the Main Military Prosecutor's Office and the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation will visit the Chebarkul garrison.

A joint visit of representatives on issues of protecting the rights of conscripts, military personnel and members of their families, as well as reserve military personnel will take place on May 20 this year.

A joint on-site reception of the Main Military Prosecutor's Office, the military prosecutor's office of the Central Military District, the military prosecutor's offices of the Chelyabinsk and Chebarkul garrisons and employees of the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Russian Federation and the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Chelyabinsk Region will be organized.

Date, time and place of the on-site reception: May 20, 2014 from 10 to 18 o'clock on the territory of the Chebarkul tank brigade (Chelyabinsk region, Chebarkul - 12).

Reception of citizens will take place in the military camp in the club, entry through checkpoint No. 2.

Information for those wishing to make an appointment in person.
Pre-registration for relatives of conscripts and military personnel: Shibanov Yuri Nikolaevich - 89511104665, 8351-2320396.

• February 27th, 2014 , 05:29 pm

Valentina Pavlovna Mikhailova, the mother of a serviceman who was injured during military service and called up in 2011, contacted the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Chelyabinsk Region.

When my son was demobilized, an extract from his medical history stated: the disease was acquired during military service. It took 13 months of exhausting battle in court with representatives of the Ministry of Defense to prove that her son received not a disease, but a military injury.

In the Chebarkul garrison, in which her son served, during the passage military training On the sports ground, a fight broke out between her son and another serviceman, as a result of which he received a traumatic brain injury. After contacting the military prosecutor's office and investigating this incident, the unit commander was transferred to another unit in Tajikistan for a disciplinary offense.

No one suffered any further punishment for the injury caused to the serviceman.

The lawyers were able to defend the rights of the victim: moral damages and compensation for loss of earnings were recovered in court.

As a result of a traumatic brain injury, the guy was left disabled, suffering from memory loss, and unable to work. For 9 months he could not remember what happened to him. He is currently undergoing rehabilitation in a Chelyabinsk military hospital.

Lawyers from the Chelyabinsk Military Commissariat are acting on behalf of the Ministry of Defense under a power of attorney for the defense, who will appeal the decision of the Kurchatovsky District Court in the regional court.

According to the victim's lawyer, the behavior of representatives of the Ministry of Defense is boorish and does not stand up to criticism.

The trials to restore justice for the serviceman have been going on for three years. In order to demoralize the plaintiff, the military commissariat sent a summons through the police to search for the guy, allegedly due to the fact that the victim was a deserter. These actions were also appealed in court and moral compensation for the damage caused was received by the Military Commissariat.

Before serving in the army, the son of V.P. Mikhailova worked in the GUFSIN, dreamed of becoming an officer, and was eager to serve in the military. He had a good income. But today he does not have his own home and lives with his mother in a semi-detached apartment.

Valentina Pavlovna, mother of a serviceman: “My son served honestly, but was injured. Became disabled. Now he is unable to earn an apartment. Due to his status as a combat veteran, he has the right to receive an apartment. The state is obliged to protect the rights of military personnel. I am simply surprised by such a boorish attitude towards its citizens on the part of the Russian Ministry of Defense, which is obliged to protect them. The actions of the Ministry of Defense undermine the authority of the army. The attitude of citizens towards the army is already “below the plinth”. Who will go there voluntarily to serve if the Ministry of Defense behaves like this? Protects the interests of the department, not citizens? “I appeal to the Commander-in-Chief, Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin, with a request to take us under his protection.”

Lawyer Alexey Kovalev comments on the situation:

“As evidenced by the case materials, the actions of the Ministry of Defense in conducting trial with endless appeals against court decisions, the right to a fair trial is violated. It is necessary that insurance payments be started as quickly as possible for the citizen, because he needs to live on something and continue rehabilitation. Secondly, it is necessary to resolve the housing issue. The rights of a military serviceman must be fully restored, because we are talking about justice, trust in the authority of state power and the military department.”

I would like to point out three things that are worth paying attention to in this matter.

Firstly, no one bore real responsibility for concealing objective information about the incident; the RF Ministry of Defense continues to confront the mother and the soldier in protecting his rights. This is not the first time that the Ministry of Defense tries to conceal facts of injuries and tragic incidents or present them in a different light.

Second: the administrative machine of the Moscow Region is designed in such a way that each of its bodies transfers responsibility to each other by simple manipulation. An indicator of this cynicism is the consideration of this case in court, when lawyers declare that the Moscow Region is an improper defendant, and propose either a military unit or Cossacks as a defendant, because the name of the unit contains the word “Cossack”.

The bottom line is that the Ministry of Defense is appealing the court decision, which the victim in the case has been seeking for a long time. It is doubly sad that no one from the Ministry of Defense bothered to personally communicate with the mother of a soldier who actually suffered as a result of serving in the army, and only two lawyers make decisions by proxy, which undoubtedly undermines the authority of the authorities and the rule of law.

I appeal to Defense Minister Shoigu with a request to withdraw the complaint against the decision of the court of first instance and ask the responsible persons to do everything possible to resolve the conflict, and not fight with citizens.

Thirdly, there are not many lawyers working in the military industry. According to lawyer Kovalev, threats are already being made against him from the Ministry of Defense that lawyers will do everything to counter his practical activities in protecting the rights of citizens. This position is puzzling and is a violation of the right to exercise professional activity.

Alexey Kovalev's phone number: 89194058321.

• February 6th, 2013 , 09:54 am

I am posting the report of the commission inspection of the Chebarkul garrison

Commission inspection of military units

02/01/2013 Chebarkul

Commission consisting of:

Sevastyanov Alexey Mikhailovich - Commissioner for Human Rights for the Chelyabinsk Region,
Shibanov Yuri Nikolaevich - head of the department of the Office of the Commissioner for Human Rights for the Chelyabinsk Region,
Chubenko Zhanna Vasilievna - Assistant to the Commissioner for Human Rights for the Chelyabinsk Region,
together with the Deputy Commander of the Central Military District (CMD) for educational work A.M. Tsygankov, the head of the medical service of the Central Military District A.A. Kalmykov, the senior assistant to the military prosecutor of the Central Military District P.V. Chepikov, the military prosecutor of the Chebarkul garrison D.P. Shuvarkin, deputy military prosecutor of the Chebarkul garrison K.R. Shamsutdinov, commander of military unit 89547 A.N. Mordvichev, acting commander of military unit 71316 P.V. Bespalym, representatives of the public and the media, representatives and officials of the military unit
units, in accordance with reports of the death of conscript soldiers as a result of the disease, D. Glebova and S. Karabatov conducted a commission visit to military units 89547 and 71316 of the Chebarkul garrison of the Central Military District, stationed in the Chelyabinsk region.

1. An examination of the soldiers’ barracks was carried out, where the personnel are housed, including young recruits who arrived at the unit at the end of 2012. The personnel of military unit 89547 were in training and were on daily duty in the barracks; Most of the personnel of military unit 71316 are on training exercises in the Totsk garrison Orenburg region, the rest are in training, there was a daily outfit in the barracks, also the acting commander of the brigade, Bespaly P.V., who explained that the soldiers were placed in cubicles. The cabin consists of a small room for 4 people; the barracks have a toilet, washbasin, shower, sports corner, and leisure room. Ventilation in the cockpits does not work; ventilation occurs by opening the window. The air temperature in the barracks corridor is 19-20 degrees Celsius, in the cubicles 23-25 ​​degrees Celsius, which corresponds to the statutory requirements. Also in the barracks there is a room for drying clothes, the heating pipes are hot, the temperature in the dryer is 45-50 degrees Celsius, which also meets the statutory requirements. All cockpits are in perfect order.

The information board for soldiers contains information about where to immediately contact them in the event of hazing or other emergency situations (military prosecutor's office).

Similar conditions were noted in the personnel barracks of military unit 89547.

2. Inspection and walk-through of medical unit 71316 was carried out:
15 military personnel are undergoing treatment and examination, of which 8 people were drafted in spring - summer 2012 and 7 people were drafted in autumn - winter 2012. Of these, 10 people are suffering from colds; 2 - with surgical diseases; 3 - in rehabilitation after acute bronchitis. 16 military personnel are being treated at the district military hospital in Yekaterinburg, of which 7 people have pneumonia, 7 people have other colds;
2 people - in psychiatry, and they were called up to the RF Armed Forces with existing diseases, which indicates improper performance of official duties by the draft commissions.

According to the results of a conversation with soldiers undergoing treatment in the medical unit: there are no cases of hazing in the unit, they are fully provided with all types of allowances, pneumonia occurs, but those who fall ill are immediately hospitalized.

Medical center doctor employee Esin A.A. in the conversation he explained: that the unit’s medical center is equipped with a mobile X-ray, so all military personnel, when their body temperature rises above 37 degrees, undergo an X-ray to detect pneumonia, and if it is detected, a car is in constant readiness in the unit’s fleet, which takes sick soldiers to the hospital, while The temperature of military personnel is constantly checked in winter. In addition, twice a week on Tuesday and Thursday, soldiers complaining of health conditions are taken to the hospital for consultations with specialist doctors. Regarding the serviceman Karabatov S., the doctor at the first-aid post explained that the latter’s pneumonia was detected in a timely manner and he was immediately sent for inpatient treatment to the Chelyabinsk garrison hospital, and then to the district hospital in Yekaterinburg. Head of the medical service of the Central Military District Kalmykov A.A. added that Karabatov died not due to late hospitalization, but due to a complicated infection and weak immunity, because Emergency measures were taken in the hospital, including artificial ventilation of the lungs, for which expensive filters were delivered from Moscow. At the same time, the chief pulmonologist of the Sverdlovsk region and the pulmonologist of the Main Medical Directorate of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation participated in the treatment of Karabatov.

3. Conversation of the commission with military personnel of unit 71316 in the garrison club.
All conscript soldiers are dressed and wearing shoes in uniform, the uniform is new. As a result of the survey, no complaints about living conditions were received. Cell phones have not been taken away from anyone; they have the opportunity to contact their parents. There are no complaints about the food. They are engaged in physical training and studying the General Military Regulations of the RF Armed Forces. According to the soldiers, there were no cases of hazing; the incidence in the unit was not higher than the epidemiological threshold. In a conversation with serviceman D. Kotov, it was found out that S. Karabatov had no complaints about his health; as soon as he fell ill, he was immediately hospitalized. He asked Karabatov what happened, the latter answered him that he had contracted pneumonia. Then he told him that he, too, had suffered from pneumonia, recovered, and now nothing was bothering him, so he told Karabatov that he, too, would recover. He believes that the latter died due to weakened immunity.

Deputy Commander of the Central Military District Tsygankov A.M. said that the district command conducts an investigation into each case related to the death or death of a serviceman. In the cases of the death of Glebov and Karabatov, the audit did not reveal any “fatal” violations on the part of military unit officials in the untimely provision of medical care to military personnel. The command of the military units of the district was ordered to carefully carry out anti-influenza measures: ventilation of the premises, soldiers are given onions and garlic during meals, thermometry three times a day, when the air temperature is minus 20, outdoor activities are stopped, in case of any ailment the soldier is sent to the first aid station, if the temperature rises he is hospitalized .

According to the senior assistant military prosecutor of the Central Military District, Chepikov P.V. The military investigation department for the Yekaterinburg garrison, following the death of privates Glebov and Karabatov, who died in the district hospital in Yekaterinburg, is conducting pre-investigation checks to make a procedural decision in accordance with Art. 144 - 145 Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation. After the inspections are completed, procedural decisions will be checked by the military prosecutor of the garrison for the legality and validity of the decisions made. In addition, the military prosecutor's office of the Chebarkul garrison, based on these facts, carried out prosecutorial checks on compliance by officials of military units 89547 and 71316 with the requirements of legislation aimed at preserving the life and health of military personnel and violations identified during the checks were sent to the military prosecutor's office of the Central Military District, after which the military prosecutor of the district introduced summary submission to the Commander of the Central Military District, which is currently under consideration.

Contact the military prosecutor of the Chebarkul garrison to conduct a prosecutorial review of the legality of conscription of privates in the RF Armed Forces in unit 71316 and in case of identified violations of current legislation, send information to the relevant prosecutor overseeing the actions of the draft commissions of the relevant military commissariat of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation to introduce prosecutorial response measures;
- contact the head of the military investigation department for the Yekaterinburg garrison, during the pre-investigation check, carefully check the timeliness of the provision of medical assistance to conscripted military personnel, Glebov D. and Karabatov S., both on the part of unit officials, because officials of the garrison and district hospitals and make a legal procedural decision.

Members of the commission:

Commissioner for Rights
person in the Chelyabinsk region Sevastyanov A.M.

Head of the Office of the Commissioner
on human rights in the Chelyabinsk region
Shibanov Yu.N.
Assistant Commissioner for Human Rights
in the Chelyabinsk region Chubenko Zh.V.

Commissioner for Human Rights
in the Chelyabinsk region
Sevastyanov A.M.

from Ulyana Vasilievna Vinokurova
sisters of a conscript soldier
Tyumentsev Maxim Yurievich

APPEAL

Dear Alexey Mikhailovich!

My brother, Tyumentsev Maxim Yurievich, passed military service in military unit No. 89547 of the Chebarkul garrison of the Chelyabinsk region since December 2010 in the engineering company. In the summer of 2011, he was at the Azov training ground, where they disposed of shells and prepared for the international exercises Center 2011.

During his service in this unit, my brother managed to experience all the inhuman torture that is only possible in our time - from the disposal of shells, constantly being in a state of severe stress from the possibility of “flying up into the air” at any moment, to beatings, humiliation and outright bullying on the part of commanders and contract sergeants such as KUFIELDOV and PATYSEV.

In this military unit, conscript soldiers are as if in a concentration camp, where the same Dagestani soldiers act as overseers and inquisitors. This entire situation exists with the encouragement of the unit commander and the connivance of the military prosecutor's office of the Chebarkul garrison.

Almost all conscript soldiers were mocked at the Azov training ground, except for the “Dagestanians”, they are in a special “honorable” position. My brother was forced to carry a bag full of gravel on himself for three weeks, and he carried it everywhere - to the toilet, to the dining room, ate and slept in it, after which he had serious problems with his spine.

They beat him so hard that 8 of my brother’s teeth were knocked out, he had a severe concussion (so much so that he could see double) after being beaten on the head with handcuffs, and his nose was broken. They beat me with sticks on my kidneys and liver. There was only one reason for the beatings - they extorted money that the guys received for disposing of the shells - the sums were very considerable, since for this work they were charged 35 thousand rubles a month.

While the cards were in the custody of the commanders, money mysteriously disappeared from them, since PIN codes were also stored along with the cards.

As a result of unsanitary conditions and field feeding, my brother developed periodontal disease. Probably, after such service, he will not have a single tooth left at all, and at the age of 24, his brother will have to insert new jaws.

Due to bullying and humiliation that could no longer be endured, my brother’s colleague Vyacheslav Tikhonov tried to commit suicide, as a result of which he ended up in a psychiatric clinic in the village. Birgilda.

My brother went to serve at the age of 24, strong and healthy, after graduating from technical school. Before the army he managed to start a family. He has a one-year-old daughter. 3 months left to serve. He had the intelligence and courage not to commit suicide, but to escape from this concentration camp called military unit.

THE THREAT TO HIS LIFE WAS ABSOLUTELY REAL.

After he left this “unit” without permission, his company commander repeatedly called me on his cell phone and threatened “that he will be found dead in a ditch if he does not return to the unit.”

Having learned about what happened, I came from Asha, found my brother and turned for help and justice to the military prosecutor's office of the Chelyabinsk garrison and the military investigation department, where the investigation into these facts is currently underway.

My brother underwent a forensic medical examination in Chelyabinsk on the street. Varnenskaya, 4, beatings filmed. The civilian medical examiner was very surprised that my brother, in such a condition, was not immediately admitted to the hospital. He was also sent to undergo a military medical examination to determine his suitability for further service in the hospital in Chelyabinsk, Sverdlovsky Ave. 28, where no concussion, no spinal damage, no fracture of the nose (fracture of the skull bones), or other injuries were noticed.

The only result of the examination was a referral for inpatient examination and treatment at the same psychiatric hospital, where many of Maxim’s colleagues have already visited, i.e. the next torture is in a psychiatric hospital.

My brother’s wife, Valentina Andreevna Balyberdina, and her one-year-old daughter specially rented an apartment and lived next to her brother’s place of service - in the DOS in Chebarkul. After Maxim escaped from the unit, she began to receive threats by phone, colleagues began to come home - unknown individuals in military uniform, who searched her rented one-room apartment 3 times a day, and who repeatedly threatened her, “what if her husband does not return to the unit, then she will have to “PAY DEPTH TO THE HOMELAND” BY RAPE. THEN THEY WILL TAKE HER DAUGHTER.”

Before being drafted into the army, my brother had health problems - a stomach ulcer, which was “cured” when he passed the military draft board. Since my brother was unable to receive any medical care at his place of service, he was forced to independently get to the city of Miass, where at City Hospital No. 2 he was examined of the gastrointestinal tract and diagnosed with duodenal ulcer, atrophic gastroduodenal reflux, chronic cholecystitis. He also underwent an X-ray of the cervical spine with a diagnosis of cervical osteochondrosis.

These medical documents are in Maxim’s hands. How long will it be possible that instead of training in a military specialty in the Chebarkul garrison, soldiers will serve as slaves taken prisoner? Russian Army? If no one is able to cope with such lawlessness, you, as the Commissioner for Human Rights for the Chelyabinsk Region, can stop the autumn conscription and make a demand to the President of the country - the Supreme Commander-in-Chief and Commissioner for Human Rights for the Russian Federation V.P. Lukin. immediately restore order in the army. How long will they maim, maim and kill in the army?

WHO NEEDS THIS ARMY!!!

I ask you to take special control over the course of the investigation in this case, to bring to criminal responsibility for everything that happened those who directly beat and humiliated; those who contributed to this, represented by the command of the unit, and those who are negligent in their immediate responsibilities - oversight of compliance with the law and the rights of military personnel - the military prosecutor of the Chebarkul garrison, and also help send my brother for an independent military medical examination.